|  
 |  
 
Gentleman's Magazine 1746 p.234 
  
[ima]ginations without drawing a sword. 
  
The fate of Carlisle you must have heard from other hands,  
we are yet in doubt whether that ignominious surrender was  
caused by cowardice or treachery, or both; I think it most  
probable that it was lost thro' a presumption that it would  
never be attack'd, and for want of a regular discipline  
among the men. The map exhibits that pretended battery which 
contributed to this false step, to which I refer you. The  
pretender's son was proclaimed at the cross, the keys of the 
city being carry'd to him at Brampton by the mayor and  
attendants; it should seem a necessary question how the keys 
of a garrison town, the custody of which was always till  
then committed to the governor, nominal or residential, came 
to be delivered into the mayor's hands for such a use at  
such a time. 
  
During the pretended siege the garrison had a lad kill'd on  
the citadel by a musket shot, and one by the accidental  
firing of a piece on the walls, which was all their loss  
slain or wounded. What the rebels lost is not to be  
ascertain'd, a person of distinction was reported to be  
kill'd near Harraby, and bury'd with great solemnity at  
Wetheral; a principal engineer was seen to fall by a shot  
from the citadel at the head of their pretended battery:  
doubtless they lost more, but I am apt to believe not many,  
because they kept at too great a distance, and could not be  
discover'd for a very thick and uncommon mist which  
continued all the time; so that the garrison may be said to  
have fir'd in the dark, directing their guns only by the  
sound of their pipes or voices. Their own reports were not  
at all to be credited, some of them pretending that the  
cannon balls had hit them without hurting them, credat  
Judaeus Apella. 
  
On Tuesday the 19th, about 100 horse more came to Brampton  
from Scotland, and the greatest part of the inhabitants of  
the country, tir'd out with finding subsistence for such a  
voracious crew, fled. I went to Halt-wesel, hearing that  
general Wade's army was in full march for our relief,  
determining to join him, but the day following that rout was 
countermanded, on hearing that the rebels were proceeding  
southward. Such was the position of our affairs, from the  
5th till the 20th of November; a long period of uneasiness  
and expence in carrying off and bringing back effects. 
  
I must do the rebels the justice to say, that they never  
used so much as a single woman in the whole country with the 
least indecency, notwithstanding the crimes of that nature  
laid to their charge: 'Tis said that their prince had given  
strict orders to the contrary, and declared that every  
oficer should suffer as the criminal for actions of that  
nature, committed by any of the ruffians under him: whether  
true or not I cannot say. 
  
All the time they lay in this neighbourhood they were  
marching and countermarching constantly, the better to  
conceal their numbers, which they reported to be 22000, but  
were only about one third of that number. 
  
From the time that the rebels left this neighbourhood, every 
day brought different accounts of them, which were all  
reported with so many improbable circumstances that they  
gained no credit. We too plainly perceiv'd that they had  
many well-wishers, who industriously conceal'd whatever  
might be to their prejudice, and exaggerated every  
circumstance in their favour. Sometimes it was reported that 
they were defeated, and presently afterwards that they were  
within a day's march of London, and that the mob had taken  
arms to support them: Every thing began to be in confusion,  
for those who had nothing to lose were ready to break down  
the partition wall that separated properties; what  
contributed greatly to our uneasiness was that we could gain 
no intelligence that could be rely'd upon; the intercourse  
between Newcastle and Carlisle, being in a manner suspended  
after that city fell into the enemies hands. It was not long 
before several of the inhabitants of that and the  
neighbouring places, exasperated against the tyranny of the  
Highland government, began to rouze themselves, necessity  
inspiring them with courage; associations were formed to  
regain their liberty, and a scheme laid to storm the castle, 
and destroy the rebel garrison; chimerical as this project  
may appear, it terrify'd the governor into an artful  
invitation of the mayor and aldermen to an entertainment  
within his precincts; which they accepted for fear of giving 
offence, and were immediately secur'd, tho' soon after  
released, on parole that they would encourage no such  
attempt for the future; others were confined on suspicion,  
and every village in the neighbourhood of the city search'd  
for arms or ammunition by the rebels, who nevertheless were  
continually deserting as apprehensive of surprize. The  
governor neglected nothing to keep them in spirits, 
  
 |