button to main menu  Clarke's Survey of the Lakes, 1787

button title page
button previous page button next page
Page x:-
  football
more, and sometimes less, into the neighbouring kingdoms; but, for the most part, found an ample supply amongst the irascible tempers in its neighbourhood. History takes notice of some of these: but without making many quotations, it may suffice to remember, that in the time of profound peace a real Chevy-Chace would have been acted in the reign of James I. but for the intervention of some persons of authority and moderation. A few hunters appeared upon the West-Marches of England: they were expostulated with; and refusing to return, both parties were gathering their strength to an effectual determination. But I know not that any thing has furnished so many incitements to mischief as the matches at foot-balls which used to be played in these parts, province against province. The custom is not yet obsolete; and within these last sixty years, though at that time the animosity, rivalry, and consequently the numbers of its attendants were much diminished, yet it was still played with great violence, and several hundreds on a side. When men are heated with such exercise, and half angry with the rebuffs of the game, it is inconceivable what disturbance and uproar the quarrel of two persons can produce, even amongst friends and neighbours; but much greater must the damage have been amongst men inflamed by the animosity of ages. I have heard many traditional stories, which still remembered the tragedies to which these matches, as well as the hunting parties, had given birth; and in the neighbourhood of the Liddle, Esk, and Leven, they may still be heard. But Dr. Burn, in his history of Cumberland and Westmoreland, gives a regular account of one, wherein, though they fought only with clubs and stakes, yet a considerable number of men were killed. These matches, like other pastimes, were held on Sundays, or some other holy days, and by a strong similarity of circumstances present a striking picture of the solemn times and barbarous feasts of savages. Now it is impossible but such proceedings must draw the notice of the legislative authority of the country; but then the judges of such affairs were men of the same stamp with those who committed them: for the most part, they wanted little or no incitement to head and enforce the quarrel of their vassals and dependents. It was then that the consequences of these baubles became more or less noticed by real history; and afforded, as I said before, sometimes a cause, and often a plea to great and national wars.
The almost uniform train of circumstances which affected these countries from their border situation, and the little difference there was between one of the dark ages and another, strongly induce me to believe, that the Northern people were little altered in manners from very remote times, to those immediately preceding the reign of Queen Elizabeth; and the subject I have been treating upon tempts me to relate one story, as an exemplification of it. Guthrie, in his History of England, says, "that a Welsh Chronicle, of an old date, mentions a battle fought at Arderydd, (probably Arthuret,) upon the borders of Scotland, between Aidan Uradog, or the Treacherous, and Guendeleu, British Princes in the North of England, on the one side; and Reiderck Hoel, Prince of the same country, on the other,upon no more important a quarrel than a lark's nest and two dogs. This battle was fatal to Guendeleu, who was killed, and Aidan was obliged to fly to the Isle of Man."
  Debatable Ground
There still remains to mention another trifle, which was a nursery to the disorders, and an inexhaustible source of contention: this was the debateable ground; of which I shall relate nothing but what the order for its settlement in the days of Edward VI. authorises. Its length could not exceed 5 miles, extending from Esk to Sark at Dimmisdale Syke-foot, and thence to Kirk-ling: yet this was only the boundary of the kingdoms then made; for the real boundary was never known before, with certainty, in this piece of ground, on account of the immemorial disorders which had prevailed there, and even the antiquity of its being debateable was too remote for the longest-lived tradition. It is said that this trifling piece of ground, from the most trifling circumstances, and given birth to prodigious, and, if we respect the causes, astonishing commotions between the two kingdoms; being the sink and receptacle of proscribed wretches, who acknowledged neither King, obeyed the laws of neither country, and feared no punishment: that hence they grew to such a pitch of boldness, as to live en-
tirely
gazetteer links
button -- "Debateable Ground" -- Debatable Land
button next page

button to main menu Lakes Guides menu.