button to main menu  Clarke's Survey of the Lakes, 1787

button title page
button previous page button next page
Page xvii:-
[de]clared, that in every plea between a plaintiff and defendant that affected life and limb, that is, which was to be decided by combat, if the defendant happened to die within the fifteen days preceding the day of trial, his body should be carried to the Marches at the time, and to the place appointed between the two parties, because no man can be assoigned by death. Again, When the appellant delayed his appearance beyond the appointed day, the defendant ought to pass to the Marches, and obtain an attestation from three Barons that he had regularly made his appearance on the day prefixed; and this being signed by them, he was totally exempted from being liable to any challenge upon that score for the future. He had also a right, if any, or all of those Barons to whom he made application should refuse to give such testimony, to oblige even them to decide the matter by combat; and the same privilege extended also to the appellant. Stolen goods were, like debts, demanded upon oath, and might be recovered, unless the person in whose possession they were found chose to deny it; the matter was then referred to the usual mode of decision. With respect to the issue, or, to speak more in the language of the times, conviction of these trials by combat, it is worthy of notice, that whether a person was found guilty, by this means, of theft, or robbery, or murder, his atonement was made by a forfeiture of goods, and he was obliged to find sureties for the completion of this atonement; in consequence of which, there were particular laws respecting the convict, his sureties, and the pursuer. An asylum was, amongst the other circumstances of these laws, allowed to any malefactor who fled from one kingdom to the other: and when he passed from one district or province of the kingdom, in which he had taken refuge, he was entitled to protection upon application to the Sheriff of that district or province into which he entered: or if he could not find the Sheriff, he might still obtain peace and protection, by ringing the bells of the first church at which he arrived within such precincts: but on the contrary, if he could be seized by those from whom he had escaped before he performed what was by them called "obtaining peace," in this manner, he might be carried back without opposition. Yet when a quarrel arrived at those circumstances, in which it could only be decided by combat; that is, when one person denied the claim of another, it might still be evaded within the fifteen days, which were generally allowed by ancient custom, as preparatory to such decision: for it was provided, that if the person accused should bring the animal, on account of which the litigation had risen, to the Marches on the day appointed for the combat, and there inform the opposite party that he believed that the property in question belonged to that party, he was exempted from the necessity of a combat; but was obliged to drive the animal into the Tweed or Esk; and if it was drowned before it reached the mid-stream, he was still answerable for it. We know not how they managed this business when the matter of dispute was such as could neither wade nor swim across, for we find no institution regarding the restoration of inanimate property.
It is needless to make any further reflection upon these laws, than what every one will make upon perusing them in these days of regularity and peace, viz. What such mortals must they have been, amongst whom such customs had prevailed from immemorial times, and for whom such laws were fabricated! However, from what is already said on this subject, I think any person may form some idea of the men who formerly inhabited the districts comprehended in these plans, and the parts contiguous. To be more copious would, perhaps, be superfluous, as any reader of common attention may find abundant examples of their temper and manner of life in the history of the dissensions and wars between the English and Scots. I only beg leave to mention here, that the lands were held by a sort of military service peculiar to their situation; that when the beacons were fired, every man was to become a soldier; and that the hornage, sergeant's-oats, and a vast number of other dues, rents, and perquisites, of an almost singular kind, are to this hour indubitable proofs of the unhappy condition of these counties in former times. I think also, that I have said enough towards proving my original propositions concerning the leading characteristics which marked the people of the Northern parts of England, and towards demonstrating the effects of habitual infelicity, and a life never void of fear. I shall therefore conclude this subject
with
button next page

button to main menu Lakes Guides menu.